Literary reviews by Tim Love.
Warning: Rather than reviews, these are often notes in preparation for reviews that were never finished, or pleas for help with understanding pieces. See Litref Reviews - a rationale for details.

Sunday, 22 November 2026

"New Zealand short stories" by Vincent O'Sullivan (ed) (OUP, 1975)

Stories written between 1965 and 1974.

  • "A final cure" (Frank Sargeson) - When the protagonist (a doctor) separates from his family, his oldest son Roger, still at school, helps him find lodgings. He'd developed an idiosyncratic way of dealing with patients that had scared them off. His wife (whose family fortune supported him) thought him mad. His old patients visit him. Police arrange a sting operation. He moves to a rest home. The ending is "when his health is inquired about he consistently replies that he is confident of moving steadily towards a final cure"
  • "Bluff retrospect" (Dan Davin) - he visits a place that his extended family visited when he was a boy to have picnics. His father was of Irish stock. Once they were told to move by an old Maori woman - they were pinicking on a Maori cemetery. He sees connections between England's treatment of the Irish and their treament of the Maoris.
  • "Another kind of love" (Roderick Finlayson) - The protagonist's a Maori bus driver in Adelaide. He can't speak the Maori language - his father had been punished for speaking it. On a stopday (strike?) he takes a coach to see Uncle Tu. He's not in - he's had to sell his land for the sake of tourism, and is working in a factory. "What the use me coming back to my people that I cannot speak to?". He returns home.
  • "An appetite for flowers" (Maurice Duggan) - 24 pages - much the longest story. Hilda, divorced from Ben, lives alone, working in a florists. She has suitors - a well off married man Anthony in particular. Adam turns up - her 14 year-old son who she's barely seen for 7 years. He stays. They're quite formal with each other. A year later Ben turns up to get Adam back. He's checked up on Anthony, she's found out about his year-long business trip. Ben tells Adam to leave the room. He asks (blackmails?) her for money, promising to pay back with interest. He leaves, Adam returns. Adam thinks a policeman had been waiting outside for Ben. Adam and Hilda have a mature discussion about their past. When Adam's in bed, Hilda leaves the room, thinking she's heard a voice. [the best so far]
  • "The bath" (Janet Frame) - An old woman's been putting flowers on her husband's grave for 17 years. On the eve of a visit she has a long, hot bath. She has trouble getting out - it takes her 30 mins. She wonders whether a quick death is preferable to old age. She tends to the grave. Her parents' nearby grave is bigger. She sits down, not wanting ever to leave. Yet she does, "waiting, waiting, for one moment of inattention, weakness, pain, to claim her for ever
  • "Winter garden" (Janet Frame) - Each day Alec visits his wife who's been in a coma for 2 months - "overwhelmed by the familiar hopelessness". Each time there's no change. After visits, he tends the garden. After she dies in autumn he's always in the garden - he "potters about day after day in the dead world were nothing seems to change"
  • "The loners" (O.E. Middleton) - Luke (married with a toddler; living with his married brother) is an immigrant who's sacked from his timberyard job. Back in his hometown it wouldn't have been a disgrace. He starts hanging around with others like him, anglers. He gets drunk with one of them, apologises to his wife. He catches a big fish - a loner far from its shoal - and takes it home. His brother has just started striking. Luke announces that he's going to be the house's fish provider.
  • "Killers" (O.E. Middleton) - A man driving his family sees a harrier eating a rabbit and tries to run it over. The harrier, wounded, ends up immobile in a hedge. We get the harrier's PoV for its last 12 hours or so. A boy finally ends its humiliation.
  • "The mace" (Philip Mincher) - Schoolboy Feany joins a walking brass band because he likes the feel of belonging to the sound. His 10-years older brother Tom, who he didn't know well, helps him with the logistics of practicing. When the band leader breaks the mace by failing to catch it, Tom expertly mends it. On the day of the big parade, Feany has to give his trumpet to some-one who'd mislaid his own, but walking without his instrument Feany still feels part of the sound, and feels close to Tom.
  • "Corrective training" (Noel Hilliard) - Letters between 2 female convicts - Henny (19, experienced, demands loyalty, out soon) and Marcia, who's naive, lonely and in love. Henny's released. Then there's a normal narrative about them meeting at Wellington and deciding to look for accommodation. [I don't think I get it]
  • "The room" (Maurice Shadbolt) - The Hamiltons have a big home by beaches and countryside - 3 generations have lived there. The son Sonny likes its library. When his older sister Margaret died in her 3rd year as a student (a botched abortion?), the room she'd been renting in the city was locked untouched by her father for months, then taken over by Sonny ("a strange, bookish child"), who's starting uni. He'd visited Margaret once in the city. She'd changed - she'd had a boyfriend. Yet even after 3 years, there's little of her character in the room. He finds a poem of hers, about an experience they shared - used as a metaphor for her love of someone else - who left her? He reads letters to/from her. He deals with a phonecall to her. [the best so far]
  • "A retired life" (Maurice Gee) - 2 old people come to Cliff's door to get him to call the police about a lewd couple on the beach. Cliff (67) thinks they're old-fashioned. They go. From his window he sees the petting couple. He reads about dinosaurs until his wife returns. She still works. She's not interested in the morning's events. In the afternoon he plays golf with his son and 2 of his friends. Cliff takes more chances than he used to. The 2 friends ask to buy his house. He's grumpy that his son only asked him out for that. When home, he realises it was his wife's idea. He feels sorry for her - a miscarriage and a mastectomy. He walks on the beach where younger people ignore him and a senile old man needs his help. Back home he gets his wife a tea then settles down to read about stars. [I like this too]
  • "Right-hand man" (Maurice Gee) - Victor, 73, has been a councillor for decades, right-hand man for dead Mayor Frank. He's on no committees now. Olga is fat and dying and still principled. He schemes a plan to have some of her cherished trees sawn down, and wins. Frank's art-loving son Mark protests, wanting himself arrested. He tell Victor that Frank was a bad father with no friends, and had laughed at the thought that Vincent would ever be mayor. Ever the right-hand man, Frank phones the police about Mark.
  • "Black cat" (Barry Mitcalfe) - A man who'd killed 6 people in 'Nam thinks back to when he killed kittens on the farm, how the mother suffered.
  • "Wet season" (Owen Leeming) - The narrator's in post-colonial Africa. He's friends with trader Fuad. He tells his wife she should leave Faud and make the most of herself. He goes out with Greta when she returns to her parents after acting far away. The narrator nearly proposes to her. One night Fuad turns up with maybe-dead Greta who'd been chasing him - a boating accident. She'd told Fuad she was a poor actress. Fuad tells him that he should have married his wife. The narrator brings Greta back to life.
  • "A way of life" (Warren Dibble) - 2 pages. A sheepdog does what his master says ever though he kicks it. A woman comforts the dog, who snarls at her.
  • "In it" (Warren Dibble) - Jess (well over 6ft, clever, worth £200,000, a married farmer) is visited by his uncle Jim who's in debt and might have to have his leg amputated tomorrow. Jim tells him he's have to sell his farm unless he can find £10,000. Jess says "I'll tell you what. I think you're in the shit" [I don't think I get it]
  • "Summer story" (Alexander Guyan) - John, 15, a single child, is bed-bound with glandular fever. He likes being pitied. Families puzzle him. Parties scare him. He fancies the cleaner, 48, who chats to him about her family. In a moment of madness he touches her breast. His best friend Bill visits. He'd told Bill once that he fancied his sister Barber and everybody found out. He hadn't trusted anybody since. A few evenings later she climbs the drainpipe to chat with him and share a cigarette. She visits again when he's in the garden for the first time in ages. His mother doesn't like Barbara. He imagines falling and dying and realises that he needn't be afraid of life.
  • "The silk" (Joy Cowley) - Herb's dying. 50 years before, he brought his wife embroidered silk from China. Now she wants to make pyjamas from it as his grave clothes. After he dies she's upset that he hadn't said goodbye. Looking close at the embroidery she sees a man waving or maybe beckoning.
  • "A way of talking" (Patricia Grace) - Hera's sister Rose returns from Aukland for Hera's wedding. Rose criticizes the dressmaker's politically incorrect comment about Maoris, embarrassinng Hera.
  • "Between earth and sky" (Patricia Grace) - 3 pages. Somebody gives birth, I think. I don't understand much else.
  • "Mavvy Phoenix" (Vincent O'Sullivan) - Turkish/Greek Mavros, a steward on a boat, is given David's address in Sydney. He jumps ship. David and his friends talk of revolution, Mavros is exotic to them. Mavros sleeps with Angelica, whose uncle is an MP, classicist and pederist. The uncle likes Mavros. A bomb goes off at the Brazilian embassy. David's arrested. The gang split. [The most impressive piece]
  • "Freedom's ramparts" (Michael Henderson) - Diary entries of a boarding school boy in 1954 - sees the Queen at Nelson and RAF planes. Between entries, staccato'd descriptions - sometimes just lists of words about sport and bullying, or passages like "They turned the calendar of his teens with dipoldic digits until the days stuck; with paraphiliac prohibition inspissated tongues saccharined the moth of youth until be sank twinkle twinkle little star while they sang defend new zealand in the nations' Butcher van selling beef"
  • "The dead bush" (Michael Henderson) - A boy helps his father lead cattle from their paddock in the dark. They have dogs. They walk. The man tells him stories about the land and their ancestors. He tells the boy that he should walk alone on nights like this - he should marry. At the end, when he's cosy in bed, an old woman says "You can't leave land like this. If you leave it the bush comes back and you might as well never have been born."
  • "A servant of the people" (Margaret Sutherland) - The narrator's researching into cremation for a book. She visits a service then goes behind the scenes where a friendly Maori shows her how the furnace works, and how ashes are dealt with. He's keen to point out that they don't sell the coffins or flowers.
  • "The healing springs" (Rachel Bush) - Mountains enclose Deep Waters, where the hot springs (known to the Maoris) are. Kathryn is staying in a smart hotel for a week. She tries to befriend the other women patients, naked. She has trouble instinctively understanding social behaviour. She's easily upset. She decides to stay longer. It's a sort of paradise. She check out. The bus is full. A man offers her a lift home in his plane. From high up, she looks down at Deep Waters and says she doesn't regret leaving.
  • "A game of cards" (Witi Ihimaera) - The narrator returns from Wellington because Nanny Miro is ill. She lives in a big house. Relatives visit her when they want money - she thinks the narrator wants money too. She loves playing cards. Even on her deathbed she tries to cheat.

Too many "so what?" pieces.

Thursday, 19 November 2026

"Big Sky" by Kate Atkinson

An audio book. Multiple threads.

A woman and man are leaving a wedding ceremony before the marriage. She's in her bridal gown, pregnant.

We go back a week. Sisters Nadia and Katchia in Poland want to work in a London hotel. Jackson's a private investigator. Jackson's out with his son Nathan (13) who goes to public school. He owns a dog, Dido. He sees a girl being picked up in a car. Later he finds her rucksack. Julia, Nathan's mother, is an actor in a soap opera.

Bassani kidnapped kids. He commited suicide when caught. His partner in crime Carmodi might be let out soon on compassionate leave.

Vince (ex-soldier, soon to be divorced by Wendy, and sacked), Andy (owns a hotel with Rhoda), Tommy (worked for Bassani and Carmodi) and Steve (lawyer) are playing golf.

Tommy has a 16 y.o. son Harry from his first marriage with a woman who died chasing a dog over a cliff. Harry works in "Transylvania World". Tommy and his new partner Crystal have a baby daughter Candis/Candy.

Ronnie (female, 2nd generation Polish) and Reggie (Scottish, 26, Vegan. She used to be a nanny for a murderess, Dr Hunter, in an earlier Kate Atkinson book, "When Will There Be Good News?") are police put together to review a child abuse case. They interview Vince, mentioning many names of people he knows.

Jackson pretends to be a 14 y.o. girl online in order to catch criminals. Andy collects girls from the airport for Tommy. We learn that Bassani and Carmodi had set up a retreat in Thailand so that men could have fun with children. Steve was their lawyer. Andy dealt with travel arrangements. He has a list of celebs/VIPs who used the service. Tommy managed and now has taken over.

Wendy's found dead, killed with a golf club. Jackson saves Vince from suicide. They briefly chat about life. Carmodi dies in prison. Vince collects Nadia and Katchia from the airport. Crystal had been groomed as a child sex-worker by Bassani and Carmidi. She contacts Jackson, suspicious about her husband. Harry and Candis are kidnapped. Crystal is told not to open her mouth. The children escape. 2 sex workers are found - one of them dead. Vince discovers what his friends are up to. He shoots Andy, then phones Jackson for psychological help. Jackson turns up and finds the handcuffed women, etc. Ronnie and Reggie arrive. Nadia shoots Steve. Crystal drowns Tommmy in their pool. Wendy had been killed by a jealous boyfriend. The sex clients are rounded up. People lie so that Vince is free to emigrate. Jackson saves the girl he saw picked up and inflicts his own justice. His daughter jilts her fiancacute; at the altar, though she's pregnant.

Entertaining sentence by sentence with humour (though all characters share the same type) and little insights into life. It's fun seeing how the various threads connect. We get eventful bios of each person sooner or later - I've left out the Jack thread in the description above - I think it was put in so some bad taste jokes could be used. She writes well - "hooked up from the seabed of memory"; " he saw a bloody handprint on the wall - hardly a good augur. In Marley's nursery class the children had made a tree that had been hung on the wall. The leaves were the prints from their hands dipped in different shades of green paint, and with their names written on then by their teacher Miss Carter. "The tree of life" she had titled it. He wondered if Marley remembered that. She was part of his tree of life. And now she was starting her own tree - putting down roots, growing branches. He sensed himself getting lost in a tangled forest of metaphors."

Other reviews

  • Sam Leith (The novel enjoys the absurdities of its genre – winks at them, even – yet manages at the same time to do a lot of work with the melancholy and absurdity of ordinary life. ... It’s a credit to Atkinson’s dexterity that despite these clashes of tone and register the novel manages to hang together, even though the subject matter – child sexual abuse, human trafficking – and the essentially comic mechanisms of the plot, its coincidences and confrontations, seem to be at odds. )
  • David Robinson (She both uses and then makes you forget the basics of genre fiction. She takes a cliché – the maverick cop, the sullen teen – out for a spin, and by the time she’s finished with it you’ve forgotten that it was a cliché to start with.)
  • bookmunch (By the time the novel starts cooking on gas (about a hundred pages in, if you’re interested), your reading experience starts to run on twin tracks because the novel is compelling in terms of narrative but it’s also fascinating in terms of its construction)

Monday, 16 November 2026

"Hangman Island" by Kate Rhodes

An audio book.

In the prologue, Jez is being dragged out to sea.

Ben's a policeman on the Scilly Isles. He has a partner Nina, a 3 month old son Noah, and a dog Shadow. In a week he'll be married. He's a volunteer on the lifeboats. Nina wants a second child - having the first nearly killed her. She wants Ben to give up Lifeboating, but his father died at sea. Sam, an ex-convict for drug offenses in Penzance, is a volunteer too. He and popular Jez (who's just disappeared) live with the landlord Callum who's become surly. PoV alternates between Sam (3rd person) and Ben (1st person).

The boat's out looking for Jez. He won a heroism prize. They find the boat he was on - it's empty. A severed hand is found on a beach, with a Lifeboat logo attached. Jez might have had a secret lover - the young wives are interviewed. He'd suddenly broke up with Anna, a single mother who seemed to be pestering him with calls. The crew are targetted - they receive RNLI badges and a quote from The Tempest. Jez's body is found. Ben discovers that he'd had a male lover (his first) and was planning to leave the islands to do an art degree. The community suspect Sam. Ben suspects Callum of drug-dealing. Molly, another crew member, disappears then is found half-drowned. Sam disappears. Ben (with Shadow) interviews Liam, the cox, on his boat. Liam assaults him, ties him to a wire and throws him overboard so he's dragged along. During this episode chapters switch between Ben's PoV and Sam's (he's tied up in the boat's hold). Sam and Shadow save Ben. Liam didn't like the way that the heroism of the lifeboat men was being dishonoured - Molly and Jess were both planning to leave the Lifeboats. Ben and Nina marry.

This isn't the first of the series so there's not much scene setting. On the islands there's a lack of streetlamps, and people don't lock doors. Many people have boats and hop from island to island.

There's a tendency (common in thrillers) to prefer nouns to verbs when describing sudden emotions - not "He's scared" but "Fear surges through him". This offers more opportunities for metaphors. Dan uses "at a slow pace", "at a rapid pace", "at a slow speed", "at a brisk pace" instead of "slowly", "rapidly", "slowly", "brisky".

I've read her "The mermaid's cry", a later book in the series. In that too there are 2 PoV's that alternate quickly at the climax so we see the same action from 2 viewpoints. In both, the baddie has an obsession that's been brewing for ages and suddenly becomes murderous.

Other reviews

Thursday, 12 November 2026

"The mermaid's cry" by Kate Rhodes

An audio book.

Penzance during a heat-wave. Ben, 41, (his 1st person PoV) has been a widower for a few months. His wife Nina had died in an accident, pregnant. His son Noah is 3, and still thinks his mother might return. They have a dog, Shadow. He's moved (temporarily) from the Scilly Isles, where he was a policeman. He's a part-time carpenter now, working with Arthur (who makes music boxes) and Mick, who writes and has an abusive brother Pat. Ben's kindly neighbour Jim who's had problems - "depression's a funny old thing," he says. Uncle Ray lives nearby.

Ben sees a baby thrown into the sea and saves it, becoming a local hero. He's suddenly popular with the local women. The baby's single mother Shannon is suspected of being involved with crime. The local police boss Faraday (some members of the group are against her, and are being investigated for unprofessional behaviour) would like Ben to find out more about her, so he visits her. She's had a threatening letter from a worshipper of the Mermaid of Zennor (a local myth).

There's another voice - someone local who wants to sacrifice a baby to the sea to save others who've been neglected.

A local festival's being organised by Freya. Ben's been invited to give a motivational speech, and his schoolfriend Zoe (who wants a child) has been invited to perform. A child in a stroller is pushed into the Lido and taken to A&E. He dies. Ben finds a figurine of the mermaid in his garden, and a note from the mermaid worshipper. He agrees to lead the investigation. He thinks that the next abduction will happen during the festival. He falls out with the invasive local journalist and the bad police. Arthur is Shannon's father. Shannon's mother Pauline doesn't let them communicate.

During the festival a baby disappears - Faraday's grandchild. The anonymous voice says that they've hidden the baby. They're in the crowd, helping to search, wanting to be seen, then they drive the baby away, get caught in a road-block, are waved on, decide that maybe they could keep the baby. There's a big car and helicopter search. One resident after another is suspected by Ben and Faraday. PoV switches more often between Ben and the abductor, the chapters shorter. Ben, with the help of Shadow, sees a person in the sea with a baby and saves them. It's Kaitlin, who'd started the nursery school.

We get Kaitlin's story - she was sent to boarding when little, heard the voice of the Mermaid when 7. When she was pregnant with twins her partner ran off. One of the twins died. The mermaid was a comfort. She kills herself while being looked after by the police. Ben turns down the offer of a permanent job. He plans a little event in memory of Nina - if he doesn't try for closure, Noah won't either.

Excellent pacing, and I believed in Ben. I wanted more of a trigger for Kaitlin's change from passive reverence. I liked "Wisteria on whitewashed walls". Kaitlin's language, understandably lofty when she's feeling sacred, sometimes feels too wordy - e.g. "ugly cacophony of noise"

Other reviews

  • lotuswritingtherapy
  • peterturnsthepage (Beneath the story is an examination and reflection on the nature of grief, that is so considered and well written, it’s the finest I’ve read within crime fiction.)
  • hookedfrompageoneblog (It certainly does put a fresh spin on this series, but it is one, I think, that will divide long-time fans.)

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

"Continuous Present" by D.A. Prince (New Walk Editions, 2025)

A pamphlet of poems from Stand, The North, Alchemy Spoon, etc.

I went to a car festival once, with fields of Cortinas, Morris Oxfords, etc - cars loved by their owners as much as any Ferrari is. This poetry collection has a similar approach. The first poem thanks Marianne Moore "for sparking a search for the exceptional everywhere ... in the foxed mirror of today, inside the relentless weight of my own hours" - bus trips, train journeys, broken bread machines, weeds growing in guttering, Keep Calm Eat Biscuits mugs, staying on for the credits.

"Routine Appointment" is the type of poem she's perhaps most famous for. The persona is attending an appointment at the hairdressers. It starts with - "Sitting under the scissors, I enquire/ about her heart. Oh, fine, she clips,". We learn, as the persona looks at her back view in mirrors, that the hairdresser has a CT span appointment - in ten months. It ends with "And yes, her dog's OK. We're good/ at surfaces, at hearts, the brighter side.".

"The Alibi Cupboard" has a less clear plot. A child (you) "Just past the crawling stage" pulls itself up at a cupboard. "You want to slip the catch,/ play with the alibis your future holds - ... missed buses ... homework-eating dogs ... grandmother's ten funerals". "your parents are ... not yours but cuckoo-substitutes, the reason everything goes wrong." At the end you are "already/ learning, clutching at the lies that lie/ before you, all your lovely other lives."

Though mostly free verse there's a sestina ("The Road Abroad"), some end-rhyme ("Weeds" is "abab"), and pseudo-sonnets ("Shades" is nearly "abcd abcd abcd abcd xx", "Staying on for the credits" is 8-6 without rhyme).

Other reviews

  • Jonathan Davidson (these are not showy poems and although they feel as though they have come directly from a life lived, they almost always look outwards, look closely at others, noticing pertinent details)
  • Kate Noakes (These are precise lyrics with not a word out of place. Prince is a consummate poet with keen observational skills and formal dexterity.)
  • Rowena Sommerville
  • Emma Lee (Through “Continuous Present”, D A Prince effectively presses pause, giving readers space to dwell in the moment. To create a period of time to focus on word choice or study the paint strokes, to see how small details accumulate and cohere into a complementary whole.)

Tuesday, 10 November 2026

"Breaking Point" by Edel Coffey

An audio book.

New York. Susannah (46) is a children's doctor, "Dr Sue" on TV. She'd married her older husband John because she'd wanted a child. They haven't made love much recently. She has 2 daughters by IVF - 6 months and 4 years. One day she leaves the baby in the car when she parks it at work. The baby dies. John is sympathetic. Susannah's ex Ralph is at the funeral. Susannah wants another child. She overdoses, recovers. There's a court case to decide if she's been negligent. Her career-orientated approach to life may count against her, though she sees work rather as her life-saving duty. She become pregnant. John doesn't seem happy. She wonders whether he's having an affair - his ex had warned her about his tendencies.

TV news reporter Adelade, black, is put on the case. 10 years before, her 2 month old baby died - a cot death. Susannah had been the doctor. Adelade's husband had killed himself. Adelaine has qualms about hounding Susannah but she's under pressure at work - they don't know about her past - so she resorts to subterfuge to get a good story. She suffer prejudice from shop security guards etc.

Susannah's coached for the trial - when to cry etc. She says that when she had weeks off for maternal care with her first baby, female colleagues had said that the consequent disruption had made it difficult for them to take time off. She wants to be strong and controlled in court but her lawyer says she should appear vulnerable. Adelade watches - she discusses feminist issue with her white friend/colleague Julie who's into Tinder. Julie sets up a meeting with an expert witness, Michael - "the chemistry was spectacular". They have sex - her first as a widow. She can't cope, and sends Michael away.

John admits that he's been sleeping with a colleague. Susannah agrees that she hasn't helped him through his grief and suggests they try again. Adelade's in a cafe when Suasanah joins her. Adelade tells her about her past. She hadn't talked about it before. They compare experiences, and discuss how another child might help. Adelade apologises to Michael.

Susannah is found guilty by the jury. The female judge speaks in her favour and against society, reversing the jury's unaminous verdict. No custodial sentence. Adelade decides that she should be a more principled journalist, refusing some jobs. She tells Michael about her past.

Susannah has a miscarriage, which ends the relationship. 2 years later, Susannah and John are happier. Susannah's more of a mother. Ralph contacts her after years. She ignores him. She starts publishing again - "Parenting and Failure". Michael and Adelade have a baby.

Too formulaic - old arguments replayed. Didn't Adelaide miss Curtis? What happened to Susannah's relationship with her remaining daughter Emma before the trial?

Other reviews

Monday, 9 November 2026

"The bewitched bourgeois" by Dino Buzzati (New York Review Books, 2014)

50 stories in chronological order (1936-1983). The introduction says he was a journalist on Corriere della Sera and had many stories published in it, as well as in many other journals. Every so often he collected stories into a book. He hovered on the realism/fantasy border - Magic Realism perhaps - happy to leave the reader unsure whether the non-realism was the result of the protagonist's madness. Some pieces are spoof articles using a documentary style. Some pieces (e.g. "The Saucer" and "Appointment with Einstein") are very like The Twilight Zone. A few (e.g. "The seven messengers") are Borgesian - they work on the page but would be hard to put on TV.

There's quite a range of lengths too. "Panic at La Scala" is 39 pages long. People (including Cottes, who's worried about where his son Arduino is) are inside La Scala when it's rumoured that the Morzi have provoked a riot/revolution outside. Nobody wants to leave. When Cottes does, the others think he's been killed. The other pieces are much shorter than that - "The Caliph Awaits Us" is only 0.5 pages long.

The ideas? There's quite a range of those too, though similarities emerge. "The shadow of the south" and "Personal escort" both use the idea of a man thinking that he repeatedly (and impossibly) sees the same man from afar in different places. The predictabililty of "Seven floors" and "The gnawing worm" are their point, but I wasn't impressed by the pieces. Some pieces involve someone adopting a temporary disguise or role that gradually becomes a permanent one. There are recursive or iterative stories that avoid infinite regress by ending where they began - an ouroboros structure. There are secret or strange rules.

  • "The Bewitched Bourgeouis" is the first piece with an unresolvable ending - a man shot in the chest with an arrow during a country walk returns to his hotel and sees his wife.
  • I like "Time Machine", looking at the complications when time goes more slowly in one town.
  • In "The writer's secret" a once acclaimed writer says that after early success he deliberate wrote badly so that his rivals wouldn't be so depressed. He says that his good stuff is hidden away in a box. After his death, the box is found to be full of blank pages.
  • "The Wind" seems weak

We're in the 1960s now. I think that even when the stories use structures he's used earlier, now there are better twists.

  • "Confidential" is a letter from Buzzati to his editor, explaining that for 30 years someone else has been writing his acclaimed stories and has been getting most of the fees. People have been surprised that Buzzati's not rich. The writer keeps asking for more money, so Buzzanti asks for a rise.
  • "The Columber" is another story where a character repeatedly sees someone/something. This time a shark is following the main character, and there are 2 twists.
  • "The Jacket" falls into a sequence, but unlike some stories written decades before, there's a satisfying twist.
  • In "The Falling Girl" (less than 5 pages) a girl jumps from at least the 500th floor of a skyscraper, slow enough to have brief exchanges with people on balconies. Several others are falling. At the end a couple debate the pros/cons of their life on the 27th floor - only old women pass, but at least the couple can hear the thuds.
  • In "Kafka's House" Buzzati is fed up being compared to Kafka. He visits Prague.

We're in the 1970s - not the best period

  • "A Boring Letter" is weak.
  • "Stories in Tandem" has a good plot.

It's difficult writing this genre of story without resorting to phrases like "strangely mysterious", which after a few repetitions lose their power. I think "a yellowish color" (p.141) should just have been "yellowish".

Other reviews

  • Karl Straub (The pleasurable frisson a writer like Buzzati creates on the page covers much of the same subtext as the fairytale: the inevitability of death, the mistakes we make in trying to outrun it, and the strangeness we encounter when fate breaks through society’s facade. His stories work seemingly endless variations on plots and settings that accomplish this; his characters become aware of fate early on in a tale, in the guise of a mysterious figure, or a supernatural creature, or a threat that gathers steam outside the building where they try to hide from it. Other times, the building itself becomes the threat, the instrument of fate. Many of his finest stories use the image of the tall building as both setting and metaphor.)
  • Valentina Polcini (The idea of being bewitched is one of the threads that links together many of the texts in this collection, including the title story. Bewitchment for Buzzati’s characters means coming into contact with the strange side of human existence (“strange” being a high-frequency word in Buzzati), which we don’t normally see because it lies behind the repetitive yet reassuring facade of our daily routines. Discovering the irrational side of reality results in the realization of some sad truths about life or, alternatively, in the awareness that our existence would be unbearably pointless without fantasy—and this is also where the metafictional aspect of Buzzati emerges. ... Venuti also preserves the author’s attention to important recurring words, usually conjunctions or adverbs, that Buzzati uses to signal the moment when fantasy takes over ... using a variety of fantastic modes and genres: allegory, fairy tale, horror, gothic, the occult, the absurd, science fiction, even dystopian fiction.)
  • Mario Naves (As a stylist, Buzzati is dour and dry, though capable of poetic and sometimes jarring turns of phrase. ... Among the finest of the tales and, in a perverse way, the funniest comes early on. “Seven Floors”)