Literary reviews by Tim Love.
Warning: Rather than reviews, these are often notes in preparation for reviews that were never finished, or pleas for help with understanding pieces. See Litref Reviews - a rationale for details.
Showing posts with label 'The Guardian Summer short story special 2007'. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 'The Guardian Summer short story special 2007'. Show all posts

Sunday, 12 August 2007

"The Guardian Summer short story special" (Weekend, 11.08.07)

The Guardian newspaper supports the short story on-line and off. This paper edition offers a 50/50 US/UK male/female split. About 18 pages of text, so we should be grateful, but about 12 pages of pictures. The demographic? Well, there are 3 old narrators and 2 adulterers and 2 pregnancies. I was interesting in seeing what kind of stories were chosen.

  • Jay McInerney's story was telly - a man commits adultery; his pregnant wife insists that his old cat is put down; when his wife gives birth he dates the vet's receptionist. I didn't see much in it.
  • Rose Tremain's story has short-storyist remembrance and an 80 year-old main character whose deeper thoughts (but only those!) seem less his than the author's.
  • Yiyun Li's starts in China 50 years ago - a grand-daughter's questioning brings out the past.
  • John Burnside's busy being John Burnside - glimpses, ghosts, muted light, mysterious beautiful women, self, world, soul, matter. It was the only piece with paragraphs worth keeping for later.
  • Nick Hornby supplied a page of bios.
  • Joshua Ferris combined pregnancy, fears of global warming, and a fat neighbour's anguished dog into a plot which ended when the woman agreed to spend $8000 on vet fees.
  • Jeanette Winterson has a woman caught in the floods and a husband wondering how to break the news of his adultery to her. This is the only piece with any magic fantasy, though it could be hallucination.
  • In AM Homes' piece, a once-famous writer gets a job as a clothes shop assistant, and takes his new workmates to an unexpected award ceremony.

I like the Burnside piece, pretentious though it might be in the context. Most of the others seemed rather slow to get started and lacked crisp descriptive detail. Most were character-driven - I turned the pages to see what would happen to the main character rather than to see how the plot would twist and turn.