David is haunted by recurrent dreams. Some turn out to be premonitions. When the dreams predict a death he burns all boats trying to save a life. But sometimes the dreams are only dreams. I thought initially that this gift of his might make the plot too SF-ish. The events aren't frequent though - they help introduce memory and destiny as themes. Water - floods, oceans, clouds and snow - is another theme. He flees from problems. At the end he seeks his wife and daughter.
There are bursts of description - e.g. p.195
Flight attendants collected cups and newspapers; passengers levered their seats forward. From the window he watched the city of Miami assemble itself: antennas and rooftops gliding into view, two trucks like toys curling through a freeway exit, a green band of smog hovering over the shoreline. A crowded marina scrolled past, each boat's windshield in turn reflecting the sun. |
or this on p.316
Graves were adorned with American flags or plastic wreaths or nothing at all. New saplings had been planted in the dead midpoint of several plots, aspens, spruce, a few dogwoods. From the branch of one dangled a miniature biplane fashioned from pieces of Budweiser cans, rotating slowly on its tether of monofilament |
Remembrance is easily provoked. On receiving a letter from someone starting at university (p.189), he goes to the beach -
He went to sea one last time in a rowboat. He lay across the thwarts and felt the water raise the boat and set it back down, and stared at the sky a long time. The day he left for college his father had waited on the landing, a string of smoke rising from a cigarette in his fingers. ... This was how he had finished out his days: brokenhearted; smoke suspended around him like grief; settling into the rituals of newspaper stories - lost hunters, plane crashes, basketball scores - wheeling dollies of milk into the backs of stores. He turned the boat and rowed back. The sun was over Souriere and the sea was drenched with light. He paused a minute and feathered the oars and let them drip. |
It's not until p.304 that we learn about his mother's deathbed scene, which brings together snow, animals, windows and loss.
It's a page-turner, though in retrospect the section set in winter in an Alaskan hut could have been edited away. At the end the threads are brought together in a rush, novelistically.
Other reviews
- Kirkus Review (But it’s much too long, and is significantly marred by its climactic momentum toward a reconciliation that simply isn’t very credible. Its protagonist’s loneliness, regret, and guilt are painfully palpable, and go a long way toward making this risky book work - but, in the end, aren’t enough.)
- Publisher's Weekly (This is a lyrical tale tuned a bit too fine: Doerr's dreamy prose accords more attention to nature than character, so that Winkler, transfixed by the wonders of water and snowflakes but singularly unreflective about his actual life, is a frustratingly opaque protagonist. There are gorgeous moments here, but a stifling lack of story)
- Neel Mukherjee (New York Times) (too much brightness dazzles and distracts, and the wall of luminous prose almost fences off the reader's heart, something Doerr clearly wants to sway. A writer as dizzyingly talented and as generous as Doerr should be confident enough to do away with some of the more blinding fireworks)
No comments:
Post a Comment