Literary reviews by Tim Love.
Warning: Rather than reviews, these are often notes in preparation for reviews that were never finished, or pleas for help with understanding pieces. See Litref Reviews - a rationale for details.
Showing posts with label 'New Zealand short stories'. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 'New Zealand short stories'. Show all posts

Sunday, 22 November 2026

"New Zealand short stories" by Vincent O'Sullivan (ed) (OUP, 1975)

Stories written between 1965 and 1974.

  • "A final cure" (Frank Sargeson) - When the protagonist (a doctor) separates from his family, his oldest son Roger, still at school, helps him find lodgings. He'd developed an idiosyncratic way of dealing with patients that had scared them off. His wife (whose family fortune supported him) thought him mad. His old patients visit him. Police arrange a sting operation. He moves to a rest home. The ending is "when his health is inquired about he consistently replies that he is confident of moving steadily towards a final cure"
  • "Bluff retrospect" (Dan Davin) - he visits a place that his extended family visited when he was a boy to have picnics. His father was of Irish stock. Once they were told to move by an old Maori woman - they were pinicking on a Maori cemetery. He sees connections between England's treatment of the Irish and their treament of the Maoris.
  • "Another kind of love" (Roderick Finlayson) - The protagonist's a Maori bus driver in Adelaide. He can't speak the Maori language - his father had been punished for speaking it. On a stopday (strike?) he takes a coach to see Uncle Tu. He's not in - he's had to sell his land for the sake of tourism, and is working in a factory. "What the use me coming back to my people that I cannot speak to?". He returns home.
  • "An appetite for flowers" (Maurice Duggan) - 24 pages - much the longest story. Hilda, divorced from Ben, lives alone, working in a florists. She has suitors - a well off married man Anthony in particular. Adam turns up - her 14 year-old son who she's barely seen for 7 years. He stays. They're quite formal with each other. A year later Ben turns up to get Adam back. He's checked up on Anthony, she's found out about his year-long business trip. Ben tells Adam to leave the room. He asks (blackmails?) her for money, promising to pay back with interest. He leaves, Adam returns. Adam thinks a policeman had been waiting outside for Ben. Adam and Hilda have a mature discussion about their past. When Adam's in bed, Hilda leaves the room, thinking she's heard a voice. [the best so far]
  • "The bath" (Janet Frame) - An old woman's been putting flowers on her husband's grave for 17 years. On the eve of a visit she has a long, hot bath. She has trouble getting out - it takes her 30 mins. She wonders whether a quick death is preferable to old age. She tends to the grave. Her parents' nearby grave is bigger. She sits down, not wanting ever to leave. Yet she does, "waiting, waiting, for one moment of inattention, weakness, pain, to claim her for ever
  • "Winter garden" (Janet Frame) - Each day Alec visits his wife who's been in a coma for 2 months - "overwhelmed by the familiar hopelessness". Each time there's no change. After visits, he tends the garden. After she dies in autumn he's always in the garden - he "potters about day after day in the dead world were nothing seems to change"
  • "The loners" (O.E. Middleton) - Luke (married with a toddler; living with his married brother) is an immigrant who's sacked from his timberyard job. Back in his hometown it wouldn't have been a disgrace. He starts hanging around with others like him, anglers. He gets drunk with one of them, apologises to his wife. He catches a big fish - a loner far from its shoal - and takes it home. His brother has just started striking. Luke announces that he's going to be the house's fish provider.
  • "Killers" (O.E. Middleton) - A man driving his family sees a harrier eating a rabbit and tries to run it over. The harrier, wounded, ends up immobile in a hedge. We get the harrier's PoV for its last 12 hours or so. A boy finally ends its humiliation.
  • "The mace" (Philip Mincher) - Schoolboy Feany joins a walking brass band because he likes the feel of belonging to the sound. His 10-years older brother Tom, who he didn't know well, helps him with the logistics of practicing. When the band leader breaks the mace by failing to catch it, Tom expertly mends it. On the day of the big parade, Feany has to give his trumpet to some-one who'd mislaid his own, but walking without his instrument Feany still feels part of the sound, and feels close to Tom.
  • "Corrective training" (Noel Hilliard) - Letters between 2 female convicts - Henny (19, experienced, demands loyalty, out soon) and Marcia, who's naive, lonely and in love. Henny's released. Then there's a normal narrative about them meeting at Wellington and deciding to look for accommodation. [I don't think I get it]
  • "The room" (Maurice Shadbolt) - The Hamiltons have a big home by beaches and countryside - 3 generations have lived there. The son Sonny likes its library. When his older sister Margaret died in her 3rd year as a student (a botched abortion?), the room she'd been renting in the city was locked untouched by her father for months, then taken over by Sonny ("a strange, bookish child"), who's starting uni. He'd visited Margaret once in the city. She'd changed - she'd had a boyfriend. Yet even after 3 years, there's little of her character in the room. He finds a poem of hers, about an experience they shared - used as a metaphor for her love of someone else - who left her? He reads letters to/from her. He deals with a phonecall to her. [the best so far]
  • "A retired life" (Maurice Gee) - 2 old people come to Cliff's door to get him to call the police about a lewd couple on the beach. Cliff (67) thinks they're old-fashioned. They go. From his window he sees the petting couple. He reads about dinosaurs until his wife returns. She still works. She's not interested in the morning's events. In the afternoon he plays golf with his son and 2 of his friends. Cliff takes more chances than he used to. The 2 friends ask to buy his house. He's grumpy that his son only asked him out for that. When home, he realises it was his wife's idea. He feels sorry for her - a miscarriage and a mastectomy. He walks on the beach where younger people ignore him and a senile old man needs his help. Back home he gets his wife a tea then settles down to read about stars. [I like this too]
  • "Right-hand man" (Maurice Gee) - Victor, 73, has been a councillor for decades, right-hand man for dead Mayor Frank. He's on no committees now. Olga is fat and dying and still principled. He schemes a plan to have some of her cherished trees sawn down, and wins. Frank's art-loving son Mark protests, wanting himself arrested. He tell Victor that Frank was a bad father with no friends, and had laughed at the thought that Vincent would ever be mayor. Ever the right-hand man, Frank phones the police about Mark.
  • "Black cat" (Barry Mitcalfe) - A man who'd killed 6 people in 'Nam thinks back to when he killed kittens on the farm, how the mother suffered.
  • "Wet season" (Owen Leeming) - The narrator's in post-colonial Africa. He's friends with trader Fuad. He tells his wife she should leave Faud and make the most of herself. He goes out with Greta when she returns to her parents after acting far away. The narrator nearly proposes to her. One night Fuad turns up with maybe-dead Greta who'd been chasing him - a boating accident. She'd told Fuad she was a poor actress. Fuad tells him that he should have married his wife. The narrator brings Greta back to life.
  • "A way of life" (Warren Dibble) - 2 pages. A sheepdog does what his master says ever though he kicks it. A woman comforts the dog, who snarls at her.
  • "In it" (Warren Dibble) - Jess (well over 6ft, clever, worth £200,000, a married farmer) is visited by his uncle Jim who's in debt and might have to have his leg amputated tomorrow. Jim tells him he's have to sell his farm unless he can find £10,000. Jess says "I'll tell you what. I think you're in the shit" [I don't think I get it]
  • "Summer story" (Alexander Guyan) - John, 15, a single child, is bed-bound with glandular fever. He likes being pitied. Families puzzle him. Parties scare him. He fancies the cleaner, 48, who chats to him about her family. In a moment of madness he touches her breast. His best friend Bill visits. He'd told Bill once that he fancied his sister Barber and everybody found out. He hadn't trusted anybody since. A few evenings later she climbs the drainpipe to chat with him and share a cigarette. She visits again when he's in the garden for the first time in ages. His mother doesn't like Barbara. He imagines falling and dying and realises that he needn't be afraid of life.
  • "The silk" (Joy Cowley) - Herb's dying. 50 years before, he brought his wife embroidered silk from China. Now she wants to make pyjamas from it as his grave clothes. After he dies she's upset that he hadn't said goodbye. Looking close at the embroidery she sees a man waving or maybe beckoning.
  • "A way of talking" (Patricia Grace) - Hera's sister Rose returns from Aukland for Hera's wedding. Rose criticizes the dressmaker's politically incorrect comment about Maoris, embarrassinng Hera.
  • "Between earth and sky" (Patricia Grace) - 3 pages. Somebody gives birth, I think. I don't understand much else.
  • "Mavvy Phoenix" (Vincent O'Sullivan) - Turkish/Greek Mavros, a steward on a boat, is given David's address in Sydney. He jumps ship. David and his friends talk of revolution, Mavros is exotic to them. Mavros sleeps with Angelica, whose uncle is an MP, classicist and pederist. The uncle likes Mavros. A bomb goes off at the Brazilian embassy. David's arrested. The gang split. [The most impressive piece]
  • "Freedom's ramparts" (Michael Henderson) - Diary entries of a boarding school boy in 1954 - sees the Queen at Nelson and RAF planes. Between entries, staccato'd descriptions - sometimes just lists of words about sport and bullying, or passages like "They turned the calendar of his teens with dipoldic digits until the days stuck; with paraphiliac prohibition inspissated tongues saccharined the moth of youth until be sank twinkle twinkle little star while they sang defend new zealand in the nations' Butcher van selling beef"
  • "The dead bush" (Michael Henderson) - A boy helps his father lead cattle from their paddock in the dark. They have dogs. They walk. The man tells him stories about the land and their ancestors. He tells the boy that he should walk alone on nights like this - he should marry. At the end, when he's cosy in bed, an old woman says "You can't leave land like this. If you leave it the bush comes back and you might as well never have been born."
  • "A servant of the people" (Margaret Sutherland) - The narrator's researching into cremation for a book. She visits a service then goes behind the scenes where a friendly Maori shows her how the furnace works, and how ashes are dealt with. He's keen to point out that they don't sell the coffins or flowers.
  • "The healing springs" (Rachel Bush) - Mountains enclose Deep Waters, where the hot springs (known to the Maoris) are. Kathryn is staying in a smart hotel for a week. She tries to befriend the other women patients, naked. She has trouble instinctively understanding social behaviour. She's easily upset. She decides to stay longer. It's a sort of paradise. She check out. The bus is full. A man offers her a lift home in his plane. From high up, she looks down at Deep Waters and says she doesn't regret leaving.
  • "A game of cards" (Witi Ihimaera) - The narrator returns from Wellington because Nanny Miro is ill. She lives in a big house. Relatives visit her when they want money - she thinks the narrator wants money too. She loves playing cards. Even on her deathbed she tries to cheat.

Too many "so what?" pieces.