An audio book.
In the prolog a women on a clifftop is approached by someone who knows her, and is pushed off.
Isobel from Boston (the first-person PoV, 23 years old - it's 2006) arrives at St Andrews to start her history PhD. She has a secret. She learns that her female supervisor, Granchier, died the week before so Endercot is taking over. At a Meet and Greet she meets various students (Catriona, Sean, etc) and staff (William, who she fancies) - working out the couples, discoveries the grudges (sexual, academic) people had against Granchier.
Charles, her landlord, says that Chanchier wasn't liked and that an old book had disappeared from the library. She's chosen the university partly because Rose (2 years older than her - they were friends as undergraduates).
She wants to study the covert influence of women in medieval times. She'd left Adrian (who was married), taking drugs to get over him, drugs which she stopped using when she arrived at St Andrews.
Rose's father left when she was 12. Her mother died when she was 16. She confesses to getting in with the wrong crowd. She doesn't want to go into details. She has a lot of money.
Rose disappears. A suicide notes is found. Police are called in. But Isobel has contact with her. Rose says it's vital that the Falcone Emerald is found, otherwise lives are at risk. She goes to Italy to search through documents for clues. William suddenly appears, which doesn't surprise her. Catriona is found dead. Sean doesn't overwhelmed by the news,
William and Isobel sleep together. He says that he and Rose started an affair 7 years before. Von Keiserling (a rich academic) had promised them big money if they found the Emerald. An Emerald was found - it was fake, which had angered von Keiserling, who'd caused Catriona to be killed, as a warning. Rose is in hiding, pregnant.
William and Isobel go to a Scottish island. When William's away, Rose meets Isobel, says that William's a psychopath and that they should get away. Rose locks Isobel in an out-house. William saves her, says that Rose killed Catriona and wanted to kill her.
Rose survives, ends up in a psychiatric clinic.
Lots of convincing historical details from over 400 years ago - double agents, etc. I sought connections between the historical story and the novel's plot.
Other reviews
- goodreads
- kirkusreviews (a less robust Da Vinci Code, less complex The Swan Thieves)
- ahistroyofcrows (a Dark Academia, but not a very good one ... The main character, Isabel, is very flat, and I can’t even speak about development because this is the type of character that isn’t fully constructed in the first place, so you can’t expect development and growth when you didn’t even get a three-dimensional character. ... a lot of her choices and actions, even after discovering things that are “bad”, are just not very believable. ... One thing I do wish was more developed is the fact that Isabel stops taking medication for mental health issues, and at first it seems like this will create a scenario of paranoia, fear, and descent into madness in the sense of “is this really happening” or “is this real” that is so prominent in gothic writing, but sadly this is just one of many aspects that end up being overlooked in the grand scheme of the novel. ... some things are just included that just don’t really add up to the story, for example, the past and a previous relationship the MC had with a married professor, don’t seem to add up to anything in the grand scheme of things, as well as an out of the blue and totally unrelated to the story scene of attempted sexual assault. I was taken by surprise by that scene, and it felt very disconnected from the rest of the book)