Lia (first-person), an ex-actor, seems to have lost a child. She can't cope. She flies from LA home to her unemotional mother (who she's not seen for 11 years) telling her sitcom-writing husband Sam not to look for her. She's stalking a woman. After 9 weeks with her mother she still hasn't told her what's wrong. She met Sam, married after a year, then left him 10 months later after having lost a child Caleb (though after 100 pages we still know nothing). She pawns her ring and moves into her own place
Becky co-owns/manages Mas, a restaurant in Philadephia. Becky feels overweight. She knows that a woman is watching her. She's married to a kind doctor Andrew whose mother Mimi has married 5 times. Andrew had sex problems caused by his overbearing mother that Becky coached him out of - she lubricated herself with olive oil the first time they had sex. When Becky goes to a yoga class, a fellow mother-to-be Ayinde breaks water. Becky and Kelly (an event planner) get her to hospital. She has model looks, a Yale degree, and is married to Richard, a very famous basketball player. He flies back smelling of woman's perfume. She gives birth to a boy, Julian, and regularly invites her new friends around. In flashbacks we learn how the women met their husbands. Then they compare their pregnancies. Kelly's mother was strict. Kelly's husband Steve is suddenly sacked.
Becky wants an all-natural birth but ends up with a C-section, giving birth to Ava. Kelly wants an epidural She gives birth to Oliver. Steven, now sacked (though Kelly doesn't tell the others), passes out. Ayinde wants to bring her baby up without help. Her mother Lola sends her a book about how babies love routine.
The women compare strollers, the support their mothers provide, their experiences of sex after giving birth, and breastfeeding. Julian sleeps in his parents' bed, which displeases Richard. Ayinde want to return to TV journalism but is told she's too pretty and famous. Andrew's mother Mimi turns up at short notice to stay for a while. She's against breastfeeding. She wants to give the baby a manicure. She stays over 3 weeks.
Becky brings Lia into the group (chats with Lia give her a chance to escape Mimi). Lia says her baby was unplanned. She offers Lia a menial job at Mas. Lia goes to a therapy group and is angry about mothers who grieve about children who died when 11. Caleb was 10 weeks old when he died. Kelly applies to return to work after 3 months, while Steven is still job hunting. She struggles to combine work (20 hours/week)with childcare - Steven hangs around in pyjamas do nothing much. Lia babysits 3 times a week.
News of Richard's one-night-stand breaks. Damage limitation. Julian has a heart murmer. The woman rally around. Julian's ok. Mimi insists that Jew Becky celebrates Xmas, sending a tree and ham. Andrew at last puts his foot down.
Lia meets a woman who had another child after her first died. They talk. Her mother contacts Sam and finds out what happened. She tracks Lia down and that chat about why they've not liked each other. Lia calls Sam, asking him to fly to er - she's ready now. Becky is pregnant again. Andrew finally agrees that his mother is manipulative and needs to be controlled. His mother over-reacts. Becky suddenly decids to apologise. Somebody interviews Kelly in her home about combining work and parenting. She lies - saying that Sam is on a business trip whereas in fact he's jobless and has been send out to do shopping. Alas Steven returns early, the baby vomits, etc. He's not been helping. She tells him to get out. The girl who said Richard made her pregnant turms up on Ayinde's doorstep to apologise. Her mother won't talk to her.
A month later Steven returns promising to turn over a new leaf. The girls all meet before Lia returns home to live with Sam.
Mimi soon becomes cartoonish - not funny, just predictably OTT. The ending's too cosy.
Other reviews
- Sahar's blog (her characters do not become four aspects of her own personality, but remain four distinct and very different women.)
- Kirkus reviews (each woman starts out with an issue and each faces a challenge. Lia’s challenge is obviously her loss; her underlying issue is her mother’s emotional coldness. Becky’s issue is weight ... Becky’s challenge is her obnoxious, overbearing mother-in-law. Overachieving Kelly’s issue is the poverty she has overcome. ... Kelly is thrown a curve when her husband gets laid off ... . For Ayinde, ... being biracial has been a lifelong struggle. Now her basketball star husband is slapped with a paternity suit by another woman. But love conquers all. Becky’s husband miraculously grows a spine and quits being a mama’s boy. Kelly and her husband learn to communicate and support each other in following their real professional dreams. Ayinde’s husband proves he is a devoted father ... Lia finds peace with her loss, realizes that her mother has always loved her, and reunites with her husband. After her realistic examination of new motherhood and marital strain, Weiner pulls her punches with a too-neat ending)