"The Rose Arbor" by Rhys Bowen

An audio book.

In 1968 a child, Lucy (3), goes missing from London. DI Jones (50+, male, single) and DC Marisa Young are sent to Weymouth to investigate. Liz, 27, a reporter and Marisa's flatmate, goes there too. A lead takes them to Tydeham, a village taken over by the Army in 1943 and never returned. Liz senses she's been there. She phones her father, a retired brigadeer, who says he's never been there. His wife is getting forgetful. There's a 1943 timeline in which we learn about the big house in the village being emptied, the artworks going into storage.

Liz stays while the others return to London. She meets James Bennington, who used to live in the big house and now lives in London. She recalls having seen someone being buried nearby. The police find a woman's skeleton there. Liz returns to London. Jones says 3 girls disappeared years ago - an early case of his. Marisa suggests that Liz might be one of them (an only child, Liz was born when her parents were in their 40s). Lucy's parents have blackmailable pasts - her father (actually stepfather) is rich and secretly gay. Her mother Susan used to live in a squat.

In a flashback we learn that one of the missing girls was an evacuee picked up by a man.

Liz and James become friends. James' mother killed herself. Liz visits her birthplace in Devon, which doesn't quite match her memories. She works out that Lucy's real mother was a friend of Susan - Lark. She finds Lark and Lucy just as Lark kills herself. She finds an evacuated girl. She discovers that Alice, a maid of her family, was somehow special - her mother? She confronts her father about it by phone. That night her mother dies of an overdose. Her father tells Liz that her mother accidentally killed Alice (the buried body) and that he administered the overdose. He doesn't say if he's Liz's biological father.

An enjoyable read. It sounds well researched. Did people "process" new emotional info back then? Maybe. She's lucky in her investigations, surprisingly certain about her hunches, and not shocked (or even affected) by the revelations about her past and parents.

Other reviews

• literarytreats (the book’s strength isn’t so much in the mysteries that its characters need to solve, but rather in the characters themselves and the world they inhabit)
• historywomanperspective ( I found Liz to be one of the most frustrating characters that I have ever read. She had no likable trait about her. ... The main problem I had most with her was that she had no sense of justice. I could not believe that she sided with those who had committed horrible deeds. She did not care about what was morally right. I hated the decisions that she made, and I greatly disliked her. ... I was really confused why there were no morals in the story. ... I was really disappointed in this book and could not believe it was written by a popular mystery writer. As for the mystery, it was very convoluted and all over the place. I also found it to be very unconvincing. ... Therefore, this was Mrs. Bowen’s worst novel that she has written.)

"Here One Moment" by Liane Moriarty

An audio book.

On a delayed Australian plane flight an old lady passenger suddenly gets up and tells people at what age they'll die and the cause of their death. We get the PoV of Leo, 43, who will die in months from a work accident (he overworks, neglecting his family); Sue, 63, (who'll die at 66 of pancreatic cancer); Allegra (a pretty, efficient air stewardess who will self-harm); Paula, 36 (with 2 kids - one will drown at 7, the other will live to 103); Ethan, who's back from a funeral (who'll die of assault at 30); Don and Eve who've just married (Eve's spouse will kill her).

We get first a paragraph from the PoV of Cherry, the old lady, then longer snippets that often have a connection with the surrounding material. After the incident she recalled nothing about it. Her mother was a psychic, her father died young, struck by lightning. Her fiance died in Vietnam. She married David, a rather uncaring man half-Korean doctor who was sterile. Good sex but they didn't like each other much. She started to drink. Her husband started sleeping with Stella. They divorced. David and Cherry decide to adopt. Cherry's mother dies, but not before Cherry gets a reading from her - Cherry recognised the tricks. Cherry remarries. After 30+ years her husband dies on a plane (the same route as the strange flight).

Interrupting Cherry's story are the lives of the various characters. Ethan, fancies his wacky, rich house-mate Jasmine who brings home a man then breaks up with him. He becomes obessive, violent and suspects Ethan. Allegra continues sleeping sometimes with pilot Jonny. She bad back pains. Don knows that he has murderous thoughts while sleepwalking so he handcuffs himself at night or sleeps in a different room. Then 3 people (2 nearly 100 years old) die at the predicted age. The survivors take precautions, just in case. They start getting in touch with each other. The ones who'll die old start taking risks.

Cherry still hasn't been identified. Then after a 4th death (faked for publicity) the predictions begin to come unstuck. She releases a statement saying that she had a mental incident on the plane. In an epilogue we discover that the boy who should have drowned at 7 went on to win a swimming gold medal - after the flight his mother had made him do many swimming lessons, so he survived an incident at sea went he was 7.

A probability theme (fallacies etc) is sustained - Cherry's an actuary. I like the details - how someone pushes aside a headphone with a thumb when spoken to, how the atmosphere in a room changes like in a classroom after the teacher's lost their temper. But I was never convinced by the Allegra character.

Other reviews

• Adele Dumont (The far-fetched plot of Here One Moment wouldn’t matter so much were its characters memorable. But there are just so very many, and post-flight they mostly lead their own separate lives, only really reconnecting via a Facebook group. As a result, there are none of the complicated group dynamics that made her other novels so compelling. ... wit is fleeting, and not enough to rescue a narrative that is too baggy and a host of characters who are ultimately forgettable.)
• Anne Logan (Would men connect with this book as much as women? Likely not, as there were considerably more female perspectives, and at times, the men could be infantilized a bit (in good humour, but still, I noticed it). Does Moriarty have a bunch of male fans? Again, probably not)
• libgirlbooks
• capsulenz

"A Neighbour's Guide to Murder" by Louise Candlish

A audio book

Prologue - London. Gwen (OAP) phones the police to say that her apartment neighbour has killed his tenant.

It's Gwen's first-person PoV (with asides). Her daughter Mia has suggested she write it as therapy. She's been divorced for 15 years from Brian, who embezzled from the charity they worked for. Her 36 y.o. son Daniel lives with her now that he's separated from his wife, unemployed and depressed. Pixie moves into her neighbour Alex's spare room. He's about 50, a composer. There seems to be an arrangement that she pay the rent by sleeping with Alec. Gwen thinks that she's curious about Pixie not because she's a replacement for too-often absent Mia, but because of Cindy, a vulnerable girl who started working with her and was propositioned by Brian. She confronts Alec, saying she's tell the committee about his deal with Pixie. He replies that he'll tell them about the embezzlement (she was cleared, and it was years ago, but it won't help her hopes of election). They find a spy camera in the shower of her en-suite. Alec seems unperturbed. Gwen calls the police. Pixie moves in with Gwen and Daniel. Gwen lends her money. She goes on holiday with Daniel. Gwen tells the press about Alec. He tells the police and presses for damages. Gwen realises that Pixie sleeps around and takes money. She accepts a caution from the police and pays damages to Alec. She has to sell the flat. Alec offers to drop damages and charges if she sells to him. She becomes his tenant.

After a chat with disappointed Pixie (who's marrying Daniel) she wonders if Pixie was telling the truth after all. She checks the circumstantial evidence. She reveals that she and Alec spent a drunken night in bed together. She suffocates Alec in his sleep, confessing to neighbour Dee but to nobody else. 6 months later Gwen is finishing her write-up and kills herself. She didn't mean to leave the write-up behind. Dee saved and edited it. 2 years later, Pixie stars in a film called "A Neighbour's Guide to Murder" about the events.

I kept wanting to read on. The plot is tidy. The characters don't match the plot too well though (Alec's murder is too much of a surprise; Gwen and Pixie's sudden friendship) and too often Gwen isn't told about things (Daniel and Pixie) or doesn't react as one might expect (when Pixie spends her borrowed money).

Other reviews

• lotuswritingtherapy
• mostlymurder (Don't be fooled by the veneer of cosy crime - this is much more complex and twisted than retirement noir.)

“Elevation” by Stephen King (Hodder & Stoughton, 2019)

In a small US Republican town, Scott Carey (divorced, 6ft 4, a web designer) goes to his retired doctor friend Bob Ellis because he's losing weight without his appearance changing. Not only that, but what he wears/carries doesn't add to his weight.

Married 30-something lesbians Missy (friendly) and Dierdre (pretty and a bit mad) live nearby. They run a failing restaurant and their dogs use his lawn as a toilet. He politely points this out to them (the first time they've talked). Dierdre over-reacts. Missy apologises.

We're already 30 pages into the novella - 25% through.

He overhears anti-lesbian jokes in his usual diner and causes a scene. He tries to befriend the couple. He learns that Dierdre used to be a national-level marathon runner, and is entering the local 12k charity run. He enters and would have won (being so light yet with the same muscle power - he's "never been happier in his life") except that he helped Dierdre win. Chapter 6 is entitled "The Incredible Lightness of Being". The publicity that Dierdre gets saves the restaurant. Dierdre's grateful. When he's almost weightless he asks Dierdre to help him float into the sky with a firework attached. He lights it.

No. Were it much shorter it might have had a chance.

"The A to Z of You and Me" by James Hannah

An audio book.

Ivo, 40, is being looked after in a room (which we later discover is in a hospice). He makes alphabetic lists of bodyparts and related memories to calm himself. These provide a backstory. He's often reminded of anatomy/science lessons. Mia (who he refers to as "You") was his girlfriend years before - a trainee nurse who was a house-mate of his friend Becka. Sheila is his favourite nurse now - the alphabet game was her suggestion. His father died early of cancer, her father was an alcoholic - they compared fathers as if they were playing "Sad Dad Top Trumps". Ivo was first diagnosed as a diabetic, then he needed dialysis. He offers advice to the young daughter of the woman dying in the next room. He tells her that Mia died 10 years ago.

His sister Laura's 5 years older than him. They haven't met since their mother's funeral 7 years before, because she chose Mal (11 grade A GCSEs) over him. She wants to see him now. This upsets Ivo's health. He doesn't want visitors but she comes anyway. She says that she stayed away from their mother at the end because it hurt too much, leaving him to deal with the funeral arrangements. Mal has been in jail for 6 years. Now he's out he's got a drug habit and is desperate to apologise to Ivo. Ivo refuses to see him. Mal was a drug dealer. Mia wasn't happy with Ivo's drug-taking (which he did while she was away). He was diagnosed with kidney failure.

We learn that Mal took him to Mia when he was stoned. Mal drove them to A&E and she died in a crash.

He starts having morphine. He talks about his funeral, wishing that he could have helped people more. He lets reality go, becomes delirious. Mia talks to him. He thinks Mal visits. He forgives him and feels better for doing so, then dies.

The amount of delayed revelation (about his location, Mia's death, the reason for falling out with Laura, the nature of Mal's crime) should have raised anticipation. Soon it made me distrust any piece of information because it might bloat into something else later (maybe Sheila was his aunt but we hadn't been told, etc). In the end though I was won over - the hospice details sounded convincing.

Other reviews

• Ian Sansom (Hannah’s debut is an excellent example of that genre of sophisticated and sentimental fiction in which the terrible perplexities of life are teased into pleasing fictional shape, a genre we might call the “heavylight”. The history of the heavylight can be traced back through Nicholls and Nick Hornby to Thomas Hardy and beyond, but it finds its perfect expression in the work of the undisputed heavylight champion of the world, Philip Larkin.)
• Natalie Xenos
• Jennifer Joyce

"The Daughter" by Lucy Dawson

An audio book.

It's 1999. Jess and Ben have a daughter, Beth (5), who dies in an accident at school where Simon is the head, his wife Louise is a teacher, and Cara their daughter attends. Jess and the older Simon had an affair while they were both married years before, neither knowing the other was married. Jess had been 19 and her mother had just killed herself. Jess had been thinking of leaving Ben but he and his family had been a great comfort. Just before the accident Simon tells Jess that he's sure Beth is his child (she had his looks and mannerisms). After, Simon tells Louise about the affair.

The day after the funeral, Louise visits Jess. She doesn't believe that it's a coincidence that Cara and Beth ended up at the same school. She threatens Jess with a knife, says that she must tell Simon she never loved him and must leave town, otherwise Ben will be told. Jess decides to leave.

17 years later, Jess is married to Ed and has a 2 y.o. son James. They're house-hunting. The house they visit belongs to Simon and Louise, who moved to the town when Jess did, about 9 years before. Louise can't believe it's a coincidence. Simon visits Jess after, saying that Cara has left home, Louise is an alcoholic, and he's divorcing her. Jess tells him about the knife incident. Simon wants to know if she ever really loved him.

Next day Louise dies - a side-effect of her attempt to stop boozing, apparently. Simon sells up.

Jess and Ed have an au-pair, Sandrine. Jess's friend Natalie is against young girls having affairs with married men. Natalie overhears Jess complaining about her and ends their friendship, telling others about Jess. Things in their house are tampered with. Ed says that on the night that Louise died he'd asked a heavy to go to her house and warn her away from Jess (subsequently Ed discovers that the heavy never went).

Jess is drugged, tied up and held at knife-point by Sandrine - who is actually Cara. She says that Simon has been passively obsessed by Jess, cyberstalking her, neglecting Cara. Cara's mother told her that Cara had been told to push Beth. Cara summons Simon. He arrives. In a tussle he's knifed. While he's dying he says he wants Jess to say that it wasn't Cara's fault. In an epilogue Cara is in recovery and asks Jess for forgiveness. She doesn't think she pushed Beth after all. Meanwhile, Ben has found out that Beth was likely not to be his child.

Clunky plotting - the Natalie sub-plot is unconvincing; Simon goes to such great lengths to achieve so little; would Ed really hire a thug? Would the thug bother meeting Ed? I can believe that Jess would deliver a long, detailed Jess's debrief to her sister Laurel, but something's wrong with the novel's structure if the reader needs to be reminded of all this.

Other reviews

• goodreads

"Run Away" by Harlan Coben

An audio book.

New York. Simon's teenage daughter Paige has run away - Simon's wife Ingrid had had enough of her bad behaviour. Simon's been looking for her. After a tip-off he finds her busking badly at Strawberry Fields, Central Park. She escapes. He punches her boyfriend Aaron who he blames for leading Paige astray. The episode goes viral - hipster assaults homeless poor. With expensive legal help he avoids a charge. 3 months later the police question him again. Aaron is dead and Paige is a suspect. Simon and Ingrid go to the murder scene. They're told to go to a shoot-up den for more info. Simon is recognised there from the video. Ingrid is shot by Luther. Cornelius (who had helped them at Paige's flat) shot Luther. Luther and Ingrid end up in the same hospital.

Another story is interleaved with Simon's. Ash and Didi have known each other since childhood - both fostered. Ash kills a man in his house, then kills another. Ash is curious about the connection between the two victims. When he gives Didi a lift back to her base, he finds she's living with a cult.

An ex-detective, Elena, asks about Henry, the second victim. Simon goes to Aaron's funeral. His stepmother Enid talks to him. Aaron's Italian mother is dead, and Aaron doesn't look like his father. He's told that Paige tracked Aaron down. Why? Simon returns to the hospital where Ingrid is still in a critical condition. Her sister hints that Ingrid used to be a junkie. Elena points out that the murdered men were all adopted. She tries to track down the adoption agency. Simon discovers that Paige had tried a DNA-testing service. He gets his 3 children tested. They're all his.

Didi tells Ash that the cult leader is about to die. He had lots of son with different mothers, but only needed 2, so he sold the others. But those others are now finding out who they're related to, thanks to DNA-testing sites. That why he's been employed. Ash kills Elena, finds out about Simon on her phone and decides he needs to be killed too. When he finds Simon he's with Cornelius to get info about Paige from Luther's group. She was last seen on her way to Buffalo.

There's a gunfight. Ash is killed. Simon is shot while trying to save Cornelius. Didi falls, goes into intensive care. A month later, Simon finds Paige at Ingrid's bedside. He learns that she'd been at a retreat for a month. Ingrid had taken her there - she's stayed there years before. Ingrid killed Aaron because he'd got Paige into drugs. A year later Paige tells Simon that Ingrid had been made pregnant by the cult leader. She thought the baby was stillborn. In fact it was Aaron. Ingrid and Aaron had found out that they were half-siblings. Should Simon tell Ingrid that she's killed her son? No.

A page-turner. Sometimes I felt there was a twist too many. Didi needn't have cult ambitions. The Elena subplot is nearly detachable from the main story.

Other reviews

• baddiebookreviews (An aspect I struggled with in the book was this little subplot that was going on while the main plot of Simon trying to find Paige was going on. It wasn’t exactly unenjoyable or anything, but to be honest it just made me feel a bit lost throughout at least the first half of the book. ... I just genuinely had no idea throughout a good portion of the book what these two were doing here. ... Look, I mean everything does come together at the end of it all, but I just wish it was a tiny bit more clear why they were here, or what they were after)