Literary reviews by Tim Love.
Warning: Rather than reviews, these are often notes in preparation for reviews that were never finished, or pleas for help with understanding pieces. See Litref Reviews - a rationale for details.
Showing posts with label 'Excisions'. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 'Excisions'. Show all posts

Friday, 11 April 2025

"Excisions" by Clare Best (Waterloo Press, 2011)

Poems from London magazine, Magma, Rialto, etc. 3 sections - "Matryoshka" (family history), "Self-portrait with Breasts" and "Airborne".

The first few poems are promising, with a level of difficulty that suits me. The book sustains that quality and level. Seldom does a poem completely stump me - "Circus, Santa Catarina" is an example. Many of the poems have stanzas with a set number of lines - 2, 3 or 4 usually (and to me rather arbitrarily). Sometimes no line-breaks are used. "Who" (4 couplets) has an abab rhyme pattern. "Clear-out" is in loosely rhymed couplets. "question" is in an xaxa scheme, the rhymed lines indented. I didn't notice any other poem using end-rhymes.

The odd poem seems dutiful, documenting a significant moment without adding much more. I read poetry books from front to back during several sessions, so when I read pages 7-9 I didn't know whether the quality had slipped after a strong start, or whether I was having an off day. The subject matter is familiar, as is the restrained language ending with a poignant little twist. A daughter arrives with her father at her wedding ("no looking back ..."). A father stays in the car rather than get out with his daughter to see his dying wife ("the tissues on the table well beyond reach"). A family scatters ashes ("We'll each scatter some of her here, he says. That's fair").

Some of the pieces in the second section relate brutal facts. I think it's the best section.

The "Airborne" section lacks the formal variety of the first section, and the intensity of the second (or they're just as intense and I have a "happiness writes white" bias). The poems are often more celebratory, recalling or depicting moments of joy. There are still poems (e.g. "Sum") that I feel I don't get. "Another advent", "Partners" (which I rather like) and "Drive time" are single-idea poems (nearly lists) that, unlike similarly structured poems earlier on, seem too long.

My favourites are "Feast", "Countdown", "Recovery room", "The nipple place", and "The bookbinder".